SALEM LAKES — In their 27th season reaching the playoffs, the New Glarus Glarner Knights have finally reached the hallowed halls of Camp Randall Stadium.
“It’s a great feeling — the first time ever in school history. We’re part of history,” said senior DB Ethan Colstad following NG’s 14-0 win over Lake Country Lutheran on Nov. 13 at Westosha Central High School in Level 4, the state semifinal.
Prior to 2025, New Glarus was just 4-25 in postseason games. A year ago, the Knights won twice before falling to Lake Country Lutheran in Level 3. This time around, it was New Glarus that came away triumphant.
In 2026, New Glarus earned a No. 1 seed in the playoffs, with the lone blemish a Week 4 loss to defending state champion and SWAL conference foe Darlington. New Glarus will get another shot at revenge this week as well, as both schools reached the pinnacle contest at Camp Randall Stadium.
“Playing against Darlington, I mean, they are a great opponent. It’s going to be a great game,” said New Glarus senior QB Quinn Marty.
Against LCL, the Knights displayed a defensive effort worthy of standing ovation, forcing the Lightning’s offense to be one-dimensional en route to a 14-0 shutout.
New Glarus (12-1) held LCL (10-3) to negative-8 yards rushing on 11 attempts. The staunch display of supremacy at the line of scrimmage made the Lightning rely nearly entirely on its passing attack for much of the game. It was a fallback option which had worked out well for LCL for much of the season. Heading into the game, junior QB Will Molnau had nearly 2,300 passing yards to go with 28 TDs and 9 INTs.
Against the Knights, Molnau completed 29 of 40 passes (72.5%) for 217 yards — both of which were above his season average. However, most attempts were of the dink and dunk variety —thrown quickly to the outside, often as a bubble screen. What Molnau and the LCL faithful weren’t anticipating was just how ready the Knights were. NG finished the evening with five interceptions, three sacks and six tackles for a loss.
“We tell these guys all the time that it’s hard to go 20 plays and score. You can dink and dunk and dink and dunk, but eventually that window just narrows down, and you have to do something phenomenal in a small space,” said head coach DJ Schuett. “Our guys came up big all night along. Defensive backs came up big all night long. We had some big sacks. We had some timely tackles for loss. It was just unbelievable.”
Brayden Schmitt opened the interception frenzy on LCL’s fourth snap of the game, capitalizing on a tipped pass from teammate Brock Roth. The Knights marched down the field, and eventually scored when QB Quinn Marty faked a roll-out run and flipped a pass to Roth, who was standing wide-open in the end zone.
Senior Tyse Hoesly stepped in front of an intended target on the fifth snap of the third quarter for the second interception. Once again, New Glarus went to work on offense, dominating the line of scrimmage and scoring another TD, this time on a short 4-yard rumbling run from senior RB Brent Weeden.
The Lightning had another short-lived possession immediately after, as Molnau’s deep pass up the west sideline was picked off by freshman DB Brock Weeden.
“We’ve kind of hung our hat for the last three or four weeks, telling the guys that ‘we are playing 48 minutes for the next 48 minutes.’ At halftime I told them that they were only guaranteed 24 more (minutes) to see where it (this season) goes,” Schuett said. “And it’s going to Camp Randall.”
However, the two most pivotal INTs of the night came in the fourth quarter, and just inches from the Lightning scoring themselves.
LCL had itself deep inside the red zone at the NG 7-yard-line with just over eight minutes to play when Colstad jumped a route to the short corner, intercepting the ball at the goal line and returning it six yards.
“I honestly thought they were going to score on the first pick, but I just read the quarterback, flew the gap and just picked it,” Colstad said.
Following the interception, he sprinted toward his sideline looking to celebrate with his brethren, and met lineman and teammate Lawrence Watson mid-jump. Watson’s size and momentum sent Colstad to the ground on his back, and he smiled and laughed after getting helped back to his feet. It wouldn’t be the last time on the night he would land on his back after leaping for the stars.
On the ensuing Knights offensive drive, the Lightning held up defensively and recovered the rare NG turnover — a fumbled handoff between Marty and Roth on a sweep.
LCL again appeared poised to score and keep the pressure on the Knights. Coming out of a timeout on third-and-9 from the NG 12-yard-line, Molnau was pressured and heaved a pass into triple coverage in the back of the end zone, where Colstad sprung for the moon, intercepting the pass and landing flat on his back. While his teammates mobbed him in celebration, Colstad laid on the turf in the end zone, as the landing quite literally knocked his breath away.
“I got the wind knocked out of me,” Colstad said. “I don’t even have words. This is crazy.”
The interception — the fifth and final of the game — gave NG the ball back with 1:54 left on the clock. Needing just one first down to run out the clock via QB kneels, Schuett put the ball into his quarterback’s hands. Marty ran back-to-back keepers up the middle for 11 yards, using a second effort to gain the clinching first down and sending the Knights sideline into a frenzy.
“I just knew I needed to get that first down. Doing that spin move, breaking that tackle — I knew I had to get there and then I got there at the end and we got to go into victory (formation) and win the game. It was awesome,” Marty said.
Marty finished the game with 74 passing yards on 9 of 16 passing, and added a game-high 46 yards rushing on eight carries. Carson Prechel (35 yards), Brent Weeden (36) and Brady Baer (17) also shared the load, as the Knights picked up 138 yards on the ground in the game. LCL out-gained NG in total offensive yards 209-205, though the Knights convincingly won the turnover battle (5-1) as well as the even more important scoreboard (14-0).
“Our guys up front keeping pressure, that opens up for our other guys to get interceptions. Those other guys stopping the deep pass helps us getting sacks,” Brent Weeden said. “It takes a lot of effort. We’re playing together, and that’s what makes it better.”
Colstad added five tackles, including a pair of booming hits, to his two picks. Hoesly had a team-high seven tackles, including five solo. Brent Weeden also had five solo tackles, and a big tackle for a loss on a bubble pass late in the second quarter.
The other defensive star of the game for the Knights was senior linebacker Noah Garcia, who finished the day with six total tackles and three sacks.
“I took a lot of emotion from last year and how they treated us, and I just came out here to do what I do, and it wasn’t to let these guys get to state,” Garcia said.
After the final handshake line and celebratory high fives and hugs between the celebratory New Glarus players and coaches, the student section and parents joined the Knights on the field to celebrate the program’s first-ever state berth.
“It means so much to this community and they’re all out there coming all this way and supporting us. It’s just a community win,” Brent Weeden said.